IIRTS - International Conference on Innovations Induced by Research
Banner
× INFO: No login session created, any link to a page with protected content will result in a redirection to the main page.
Paper Review:
Paper information:
Paper ID: 1
Paper Category: Innovations in Control
Paper Title: Paper Title ...
Keywords: machine control, machine design, computer aided analysis, CAD/CAE
Paper Abstract:
The Abstract of the Paper ...
Download Paper:
Uploaded File: [ IIRTS2019-X.pdf - Paper Download Link ]
Reviewer's information for Editors (will not be revealed to Authors):
Reviewer Name: First name and Last name, Prof. DSc PhD
Reviewer email: reviewer@institution.edu
Reviewer ORCID: ORCID https://orcid.org/0000-0000-0000-0000

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR AUTHORS (will be shown to authors):
Ratings are from one star (Very low/not at all) to eight stars (Outstanding).
Evaluation of PRESENTATION:
Please evaluate:Ratings:
General readability:
Organization and efficiency:
Focus/clarity of written expression:
Creativity of expression:
Grammar, spelling, and punctuation:
Accuracy of information:
Evaluation of CONTENT & METHOD:
Please evaluate:Ratings:
Originality of approach or unique perspective:
Use of theory to support conclusions:
Knowledge of related literature/theoretical framework:
Research reviewed and critiqued:
Appropriately and properly applied research methodology:
Quality and sufficiency of interpretations & analyses:
Accurate interpretation of findings:
Clear and logical conclusions:
Use of references to support discussion:
Evaluation of RELEVANCE & SIGNIFICANCE:
Please evaluate:Ratings:
Implications for both theory and practice:
Significant results or conclusions:
Relevant and useful recommendations:
Value for an international readership:
Contribution to mission of the conference:

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR EDITORS (will not be shown to Authors):
Please evaluate:PoorFairAverageGoodVery GoodExcellent
Relevance and importance of the paper for the Conference 'Innovations Induced by Research in Technical Systems' and its main themes:  
Affiliation and relevance to 'MECHANICAL ENGINEERING':  
Rating of this paper in comparison to similar papers in highly regarded scientific conferences and journals:  
Language quality and grammatical correctness:  
If you answered yes to any of the following questions, please give details in the comments for Editors box below:
Please evaluate:Do not knowNoYes
Is the English used correct and readable?  
Do you have any potential conflict of interest with regards to this paper?  
Did you detect plagiarism?  

COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS:
Comments and suggestions for Authors (will be shown to Authors):
Additional confidential comments to Editors only (will not be shown to Authors):

REVIEWER'S OVERALL RECOMMENDATION:
Accept in present form: no revision needed.
Accept after minor revision (corrections to minor methodological errors and text editing).
Major revision needed: suggest revision and resubmission.
Reject (article has serious flaws, additional experiments needed, research not conducted correctly).