IIRTS - International Conference on Innovations Induced by Research
Banner
× INFO: No login session created, any link to a page with protected content will result in a redirection to the main page.
Paper Review:
Paper information:
Paper ID: 1
Paper Category: Innovations in Control
Paper Title: Paper Title ...
Authors: Paper Authors
Keywords: machine control, machine design, computer aided analysis, CAD/CAE
Paper Abstract:
The Abstract of the Paper ...
Download Paper:
Uploaded File: [ IIRTS2019-X.pdf - Paper Download Link ]
Reviewer's information for Editors (will not be revealed to Authors):
Reviewer Name: First name and Last name, Prof. DSc PhD
Reviewer email: reviewer@institution.edu
Reviewer ORCID: ORCID https://orcid.org/0000-0000-0000-0000

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR AUTHORS (will be shown to authors):
Ratings are from one star (Very low/not at all) to eight stars (Outstanding).
Evaluation of PRESENTATION:
Please evaluate:Ratings:
General readability:
Organization and efficiency:
Focus/clarity of written expression:
Creativity of expression:
Grammar, spelling, and punctuation:
Accuracy of information:
Evaluation of CONTENT & METHOD:
Please evaluate:Ratings:
Originality of approach or unique perspective:
Use of theory to support conclusions:
Knowledge of related literature/theoretical framework:
Research reviewed and critiqued:
Appropriately and properly applied research methodology:
Quality and sufficiency of interpretations & analyses:
Accurate interpretation of findings:
Clear and logical conclusions:
Use of references to support discussion:
Evaluation of RELEVANCE & SIGNIFICANCE:
Please evaluate:Ratings:
Implications for both theory and practice:
Significant results or conclusions:
Relevant and useful recommendations:
Value for an international readership:
Contribution to mission of the conference:

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR EDITORS (will not be shown to Authors):
Please evaluate: Poor  Fair  Average  Good  Very 
 Good 
 Excellent 
Relevance and importance of the paper for the Conference 'Innovations Induced by Research in Technical Systems' and its main themes:  
Affiliation and relevance to 'MECHANICAL ENGINEERING':  
Rating of this paper in comparison to similar papers in highly regarded scientific conferences and journals:  
Language quality and grammatical correctness:  
If you answered yes to any of the following questions, please give details in the comments for Editors box below:
Please evaluate: Do not know  No  Yes 
Is the English used correct and readable?  
Do you have any potential conflict of interest with regards to this paper?  
Did you detect plagiarism?  

COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS:
Comments and suggestions for Authors (will be shown to Authors):
Additional confidential comments to Editors only (will not be shown to Authors):

REVIEWER'S OVERALL RECOMMENDATION:
Accept in present form: no revision needed.
Accept after minor revision (corrections to minor methodological errors and text editing).
Major revision needed: suggest revision and resubmission.
Reject (article has serious flaws, additional experiments needed, research not conducted correctly).